Ice cream is a classic summer food, loved by people of all ages. Whether you prefer a simple vanilla scoop or something more adventurous, ice cream is always a good idea. And if you happen to be in Lancaster, PA, you are in luck as this charming town has numerous ice cream parlors to choose from.Lancaster has a rich history of ice cream parlors, and some of them have been serving up delicious scoops for over a century. But there are also some unique and farm-fresh ice cream shops that are worth a visit. With so many options to choose from, it can be challenging to decide where to go. But don’t worry, we’ve got you covered. In this blog post, we’ve put together a guide to the best ice cream spots in Lancaster, PA, so you can make the most of your sweet summer indulgence.
In this guide, we will explore the best ice cream joints in Lancaster and provide a brief overview of some of the must-visit ice cream shops in the town. From the classics to the unique flavors and farm-fresh shops, we’ll cover them all. Whether you’re craving a traditional flavor or a more unique combination, there’s something for everyone in Lancaster. So let’s get started and indulge in some of the best ice cream in town!When it comes to ice cream, Lancaster, PA has a lot to offer. The town is filled with a variety of ice cream shops, serving up everything from classic flavors to unique combinations. But besides the variety, Lancaster is also home to some of the oldest dairy farms and ice cream parlors in America. In fact, some of these shops have been in operation for over a century, making them a must-visit for anyone curious about the history of ice cream. And if you’re looking for something beyond the classics, Lancaster also features numerous boutique and farm-fresh ice cream shops that will satisfy even the most adventurous taste buds.Lancaster has a rich history of ice cream parlors, and some of them have been serving up delicious scoops for over a century. But there are also some unique and farm-fresh ice cream shops that are worth a visit. With so many options to choose from, it can be challenging to decide where to go. But don’t worry, we’ve got you covered. In this blog post, we’ve put together a guide to the best ice cream spots in Lancaster, PA, so you can make the most of your sweet summer indulgence. We’ll cover everything from the classics to the unique flavors and farm-fresh shops. So let’s get started and indulge in some of the best ice cream in town!
Historical Ice Cream Shops
When it comes to historical ice cream shops, one cannot miss a visit to the iconic and legendary Penn Square Grill. You can feel the old-school charm in the air as you enter this classic diner-style restaurant that has been operating since 1935. In addition to serving hot meals, this spot is famous for its ice cream, and for good reason. The ice cream here is creamy, smooth, and simply magical. It is a perfect place to enjoy classic flavors like vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate ice cream. With vintage decor and comfortable seating, Penn Square Grill is a treat for all ice cream lovers.
Another iconic historical ice cream shop in Lancaster is Lapp Valley Farm. This family-owned and operated farm has been producing homemade ice cream for over 20 years. The Lapp family has been in the dairy business for generations, and they have perfected the craft of making ice cream. It is made with the freshest locally sourced milk and cream, and you can taste the difference in its unparalleled richness and creaminess. From classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla to unique ones such as butter brickle, black raspberry, and mint chocolate chip, Lapp Valley offers a wide range of flavors to choose from. Visiting Lapp Valley Farm is an experience in itself as you can see the cows and calves grazing in the fields, adding a lovely rustic charm to your ice cream experience.When you step into Lapp Valley Farm, you feel like you’ve gone back in time to a simpler way of life, where things were done by hand, with care and attention to detail. The ice cream here is not just delicious but also made with love and passion for the craft. Whether you choose a classic or unique flavor, you won’t be disappointed. Not to mention, Lapp Valley Farm also offers seasonal flavors like pumpkin and apple cider in the fall, and eggnog during the holiday season. With a visit to Lapp Valley, you can enjoy a scoop of delicious ice cream while also experiencing the tradition and history of Lancaster’s dairy farms.
Unique Flavors and Combinations
If you’re looking for something beyond classic flavors, Lancaster has numerous ice cream shops that offer unique combinations that will leave your taste buds wanting more. It’s not just about the vanilla and chocolate – there is a kaleidoscope of colors and flavors to choose from! From fruity sorbets to savory flavors, the ice cream shops in Lancaster have got it all.Of course! In addition to the flavors I mentioned earlier, Lancaster’s ice cream shops are also known for their unique toppings and mix-ins. You can try adding coffee beans or pretzels to your ice cream at Fox Meadows Creamery or adding sprinkles and candy to your shake at the Lancaster Sweet Shoppe. Whatever your preference, the ice cream shops in Lancaster have endless possibilities for customization. With so many options, it’s no wonder Lancaster is a hotspot for ice cream lovers.
One of the must-try unique flavors and combinations in Lancaster is the goat cheese and beet ice cream at Owowcow Creamery. The combination may sound strange, but the sweet and earthy flavors complement each other perfectly. Another popular unique flavor at Owowcow is their mouth-watering matcha green tea ice cream. If you’re looking for a spicy kick, head over to Carmen & David’s Creamery and try their Mexican hot chocolate ice cream, made with cinnamon, chili powder, and dark chocolate. The possibilities are truly endless when it comes to the unique flavors and mix-ins offered in Lancaster’s ice cream shops.There are several ice cream shops in Lancaster that offer unique flavors and mix-ins that will leave you wanting more. Another example of a must-try unique combination is the potato chip ice cream at Urban Churn. This savory-sweet flavor is made with locally sourced potato chips and will satisfy your craving for something salty while still enjoying your favorite dessert. And if you have a penchant for bacon, you’ll definitely want to try the maple bacon ice cream at Pine View Dairy, where they use real bacon bits to flavor the ice cream. Overall, the unique flavors and mix-ins available at Lancaster’s ice cream shops are sure to delight your taste buds and leave you wanting more.Not to be missed is the homemade waffle cone or bowl that many of these ice cream shops offer. The warm, fresh waffle cone provides the perfect complement to a cold scoop of ice cream. Some of the shops even let you choose from various flavors of waffles, such as chocolate and vanilla. Additionally, many of these shops also offer vegan or dairy-free options, making it a great spot for groups with dietary restrictions. With so much variety in flavor and texture, it’s no wonder that Lancaster has become a go-to destination for ice cream lovers from all over.
Farm Fresh Ice Cream Shops
If you’re a fan of farm-fresh ice cream, you can’t miss a visit to Fox Meadows Creamery. Located on a picturesque farm, this creamery takes pride in using the freshest ingredients to make ice cream that is both creamy and delicious. They offer a variety of flavors, including the popular Black Raspberry, Mint Chocolate Chip, and Cookies & Cream.
They also have several rotating seasonal flavors like pumpkin, eggnog, and peach. The farm view and animals add to the attraction making it a perfect spot for a family outing.Fox Meadows Creamery is not just an ice cream shop, but a true farm experience. You can take a stroll around the farm, pet the friendly animals, or enjoy a cup of coffee in a quiet atmosphere. The family-friendly atmosphere makes it a great spot for family outings or even a date. The farm has a petting zoo that makes it fun for the kids. You can also feed the cows or watch them graze in the fields. Fox Meadows Creamery’s farm fresh ice cream is the perfect way to end the evening. The farm view and animals add to the attraction making it an Instagram-worthy spot and something you and your family would remember for a long time.
Another must-visit farm fresh ice cream shop in Lancaster is Turkey Hill Experience. This is more than just an ice cream shop – it is an interactive exhibit that allows you to explore the Turkey Hill dairy and learn about the process of making ice cream. It makes it fun for both adults and kids. You can start by learning about the history of Turkey Hill and the dairy farm, and then move on to the process of making ice cream. You can sample the various ice cream flavors and even create your own.
The Turkey Hill Experience also offers other interactive exhibits like the tea taste-testing station and the ice cream Olympics game. They also have a gift store where you can purchase souvenirs and ice cream-themed merchandise. Since the Turkey Hill Experience is a popular destination, it is recommended to get tickets beforehand or go in the morning to avoid the crowds. Come with family or friends, the Turkey Hill experience is not a place to miss while in Lancaster.Continuing from the last paragraph, the Turkey Hill experience is a perfect outing for both kids and adults alike. It provides insights into the dairy industry while keeping it fun and interactive. The knowledge of seeing how the operation works while sampling the ice cream is both interesting and educational. Additionally, the ice cream Olympics game keeps the kids engaged and entertained. The gift shop is a worthy stop to get souvenirs, and both the vanilla and chocolate milk are a treat worth buying in themselves. The Turkey Hill Experience is a spot that should be on every traveler’s list while in Lancaster, especially if you’re looking to mix in a little education and fun.
Conclusion
If you’re looking for more of a chilled-out, laidback atmosphere, check out the Lancaster Sweet Shoppe’s Ice Cream Parlor. This is the perfect spot for an evening treat, with its inviting porch, quaint décor, and live music on the weekends. What sets them apart is the wide variety of homemade ice cream cakes that are available, making it a popular spot for events and special occasions. At Lancaster Sweet Shoppe, you have six different cup sizes to choose from, along with sugar and cake cones, which is perfect for sharing with a friend or for some personal indulgence.This ice cream shop focuses on creating a warm and welcoming environment for its customers providing a cozy space to enjoy your treat.
Their flavors range from the classic vanilla and chocolate to the more unique such as the caramelized fig, lavender honey, and blueberry lemon. If you have any dietary restrictions, not to worry, the shop also offers a variety of dairy-free and vegan ice cream. Whether you’re grabbing a quick treat on the go or looking for a sweet escape, Lancaster Sweet Shoppe’s Ice Cream Parlor is worth checking out. With its homemade ice cream cakes and live music on the weekends, it’s an experience you won’t forget quickly.
If you’re looking for an ice cream shop that provides a laidback atmosphere with a touch of nostalgia, look no further than Jigger Shop. Located on the outskirts of Lancaster, Jigger Shop has been around for over a century. The shop has retained its old-world charm, with its black-and-white checkered floors, red stools, and vintage light fixtures. It makes for the perfect spot for a quick sweet bite or lunch with some of the best sandwiches and hot dogs in town.
Their menu consists of a variety of hand-dipped ice cream, including the famous Strawberry Sundae – a local favorite. One of the things that sets Jigger Shop apart is the Sundae Blitz – a sundae with seven flavors of ice cream, seven toppings, and whipped cream! It’s perfect for sharing with friends or taking on as a challenge by yourself! You can also indulge in classic treats like milkshakes, floats, and banana splits. If you’re feeling a little more savory, Jigger Shop also offers a variety of sandwiches and hot dogs that are perfect for a quick lunch or a snack while you’re on the go.
Overall, the Jigger Shop is a classic ice cream shop with an old-time feel which would be a perfect spot to have lunch with family and friends.Low lighting, vintage fixtures, and old-school charm, they have been serving the best ice creams, sundaes, and sandwiches for over a century. It is the perfect spot for a quick meal, an afternoon sweet break or even an evening bite. The sundae blitz is a must-try if you’re with friends or in the mood for a challenge. Enjoy good food, good vibes, and a good time at the Jigger Shop.Great! We have covered a variety of ice cream spots in Lancaster, PA. However, we can still add more details to some of the sections or include another section that we haven’t covered yet. For example, we could add a section on ‘ice cream festivals in Lancaster, PA’ that people could attend to try out different flavors or a section on the ‘most popular flavors in Lancaster, PA’ that people should try. Is there any direction you would like to go in?
Hi there, I’m Anchali, and I have a passion for making delicious ice cream. On my blog, I share my favorite recipes and tips for creating the perfect scoop every time. Join me on my ice cream journey and discover new flavors and techniques along the way.
